Sorry for the delay in posting the winner, I didn't end up online much yesterday as I delivered the Christening gown I made (pictures to follow later).
Using random.org, and using all comments posted both here and on Fiskateers, the winner is...Jenny's Heart! Congratulations! Please send me a message here or through Fiskateers with your contact information so I can get your new punch in the mail to you!
Thank you to everyone for checking out my blog and for your comments!